Fantasy Football Nerd
Sign In/Create Account

Fantasy Football Report Card (STD Scoring)

Below is a comparison from our preseason draft rankings to season rankings (Weeks 1 - 16) based upon actual production including an accuracy grade for each player.

Grades: To calculate our grades, we subtract the season rank from the draft rank and square the difference. An A+ means that the season rank is exactly the same as the projected rank. Letter grades are then determined based upon the incremental squared value.

Select a Position Below

Format: STD

Standard PPR
Player Team Position Draft Rank Season Rank Grade
Patrick Mahomes KC QB 1 13 C-
Lamar Jackson BAL QB 2 4 A
Dak Prescott DAL QB 3 17 D
Russell Wilson SEA QB 4 1 A
Deshaun Watson HOU QB 5 10 A-
Kyler Murray ARI QB 6 5 A
Matt Ryan ATL QB 7 8 A
Josh Allen BUF QB 8 3 A-
Drew Brees NO QB 9 23 D
Tom Brady TB QB 10 12 A
Carson Wentz PHI QB 11 26 F
Aaron Rodgers GB QB 12 2 B-
Matthew Stafford DET QB 13 21 B
Daniel Jones NYG QB 14 19 A-
Cam Newton NE QB 15 6 B-
Ben Roethlisberger PIT QB 16 9 B+
Jared Goff LAR QB 17 29 C-
Baker Mayfield CLE QB 18 30 C-
Joe Burrow CIN QB 19 20 A
Ryan Tannehill TEN QB 20 15 A-
Gardner Minshew JAC QB 21 11 B-
Jimmy Garoppolo SF QB 22 16 A-
Philip Rivers IND QB 23 22 A
Drew Lock DEN QB 24 25 A
Kirk Cousins MIN QB 25 14 C
Teddy Bridgewater CAR QB 26 18 B
Derek Carr LV QB 27 24 A
Sam Darnold NYJ QB 28 28 A+
Tyrod Taylor LAC QB 29 31 A
Dwayne Haskins WAS QB 30 27 A
Ryan Fitzpatrick MIA QB 31 32 A
Mitchell Trubisky CHI QB 35 7 F
Tim Boyle GB QB 41 37 A
Taysom Hill NO QB 61 33 F